~ ~ ~ ~ ~
Early Days of Nicaragua




Long before the coming of the Leathernecks, Nicaragua had been a prize fought for by world powers. In the year 1687, though all of Central America lay under Spanish claims, Great Britain made a treaty with an Indian chieftain and designated the man to be King of the Mosquito Protectorate (a strip of swamp land stretching along the east coast from Cape Gracias a'Dios to Bluefields Lagoon).

Spanish authority over Central America ended on 1 July 1821, when representatives from the provinces of Nicaragua, Guatemala, Honduras, Salvador, and Costa Rica met at Guatemala City to issue a declaration of independence. Plagued by revolutions throughout South America, Spain did not have the resources to challenge the rebels at Guatemala City. Free from the rigors of war, the rebels devoted their entire energies to forming a confederation modeled after the federal government of the United States. Within two years after the declaration of independence from Spain, a Central American Republic was exercising some degree of control over the five states.

Unfortunately, there were several stumbling blocks in the path toward stable government. Poor roads, exaggerated local pride, and the conflict between anticlerical Liberals and the staunchly Catholic Conservatives combined to destroy the union. For a time, the Liberals were able to retain power, but by 1839, the republic had disappeared, leaving Nicaragua an independent state.<1>

Nicaragua suffered the same ills which had proved fatal to the Central American Republic. Liberal still battled Conservative, but the hatred of one for the other was based on economic factors and civic pride rather than upon any religious principles. Whether a Liberal or a Conservative, the Nicaraguan had an abiding distrust of the national government.

To attribute the continuing strife within Nicaragua to economic differences or to the hatred of politicians out of power for those controlling the nation would be to ignore the spirit of localismo. This was a fierce civic pride, which magnified economic jealousy and enabled petty leaders to raise armies to crush,a rival town or overthrow the national government. Over the years, of course, such rivalry waned until the principal motive for rebellion became the hatred of the "outs" for the "ins." Nevertheless, localismo was for many decades the main cause of warfare between Conservatives and Liberals.<2> Since compromise was impossible, the rival factions went to war, and for years, Nicaragua trembled under the lash of rebellion.

During these years of turmoil, Nicaragua blossomed forth as a strategically important area. As a result of the victory over Mexico, the United States had annexed California and the Southwest. Since the trek across desert and mountains to the Pacific Coast was both long and dangerous and the sea journey around Cape Horn was no easier, Nicaragua and the Isthmus of Panama became vital to America's transcontinental communications.<3> American diplomats successfully obtained transit rights across the isthmus.<4> In the meantime, gold had been discovered in California, and the increased traffic across Central America lured private investors into the area.

Leader in the development of a Nicaraguan transit route was an American, Cornelius Vanderbilt, who already had begun a rail line across the Isthmus of Panama. At first, Vanderbilt and his partners, Joseph L. White and Nathaniel J. Wolfe, had hoped to construct an inter-oceanic canal; but when this proved impracticable, they organized the Accessory Transit Company to transport freight and passengers from Greytown up the San Juan River, across Lake Nicaragua, then overland to San Juan del Sur.<5>

American expansion and the increasing importance of Nicaragua had not gone unnoticed in Great Britain. With a firm foothold north of Bluefields Lagoon, it was a simple matter to expand the Mosquito Protectorate. Once Mexico was beaten and the United States was certain to retain California, the British, in February 1848, seized the town of San Juan del Norte, renamed it Greytown and declared it a free city, made independent by the authority of the Mosquito King. The annexation of Greytown placed the British in control of the mouth of the San Jean River. Commodore Vanderbilt obtained permission to establish the Accessory Transit Company from the Nicaraguan government, but now his use of the river was subject to the whims of the British Consul at Greytown.

During the 1850's, then, Nicaragua was rocked by two conflicts, the shooting war between Liberals and Conservatives and a war of nerves between the United States and Britain. Anglo-American troubles began in 1851, when the municipality of Greytown attempted to gain closer control over Vanderbilt's company by forcing it to move its stores nearer the heart of the city. The company naturally refused. A mob then rowed out from Greytown, did some damage to Vanderbilt's warehouses and offices and trampled on the American flag.

Again in February 1853, the British tried to disrupt the transit service. Local company representatives refused to obey an order that they raze their new buildings at Puntas Arenas. Fortunately, an American warship, the CYANE, dropped anchor in the harbor; and on 11 March, Orderly Sergeant James Thompson landed with a detachment of Marines to guard American property in and near Greytown. This handful of Leathernecks plus the ominous guns of the CYANE prevented any repetition of the mob's outrage of two years before. On 13 March, the Marines were withdrawn.

Relations between the British consul at Greytown and officials of the transit company remained tense. On 16 May, the river steamer ROUTH carrying Solon Borland, the American Minister to Nicaragua, chugged to a stop off Puntas Arenas. That evening, Borland went ashore to visit the American commercial agent in Greytown. A mob surrounded the agent's house, hurled broken bottles and stones at the Minister, and kept him a virtual prisoner for some 48 hours. Once the mob had dispersed, Borland began the long journey to Washington, where he reported the details of the outrage to the Secretary of State. Upon learning the facts, the United States immediately demanded the punishment of those responsible; but there was no one left at Greytown to assume responsibility for the riot. Every member of the municipal council as well as the mayor had either resigned or fled to Jamaica. Since there could be no recourse to diplomacy, the problem was handed over to the United States Navy.

Charged with the task of exacting satisfaction was the captain of the CYANE, Commander George H. Hollins. Commander Hollins faced a difficult decision. He realized that he could extract no apology for the attack on Minister Borland. His only alternative was to punish the men responsible, but the ringleaders had disappeared. All he could do was bombard the town, and this he tried to do in the most humane manner possible. Hollins allowed 24 hours in which to evacuate the town, then commenced firing. Beginning at 0900 on 13 July, 177 shells plowed into Greytown. That afternoon a landing party of Marines and seamen completed the destruction of the town and on the following day, crossed over to Puntas Arenas to demolish a powder magazine.

In the meantime, Nicaragua was in the midst of another series of rebellions. Conservative victory in the election of 1853 brought the usual reaction--a rebellion of the Liberals. For a time, government troops were successful; and Francisco Castellon, defeated Liberal candidate for President, was exiled to Honduras. There he won the support of the Honduran government and re-entered the fray. In spite of this assistance, the Liberals were unable to win a conclusive victory, so Castellon began looking further afield for reinforcements.

The Liberal campaign was dragging on when Castellon poured out his troubles to a visiting Californian, Byron Cole, who offered an easy solution to the problem. Cole contacted his close friend, a diminutive native of Tennessee, William Walker. In return for cash and land grants, Walker offered to provide 300 "colonists subject to military duty" for service in the Liberal army.

William Walker was no novice at dabbling in revolution. Earlier in his career, he had organized a private army and invaded Lower California. Disease, starvation, and the lack of support by the natives combined to defeat him; but he escaped to California ready to embark on some new adventure.<6>

In the summer of 1855, Walker arrived in Nicaragua with the first contingent of "colonists." The fighting that followed was directed almost exclusively by the tiny American. A truce was granted, and in October 1855, a new Liberal government took office. Patrico Rivas, a moderate Conservative, took office as President, a move designed to appease the opposition, while Walker looked out for the Liberal cause as Commander in Chief of the Army.

In February 1856, Walker forced Rivas to revoke the charter of the Accessory Transit Company and turn over its rights to a new concern. Cornelius Vanderbilt vowed revenge. Walker seemed eager to lead Nicaragua out of the wilderness, an objective he could best accomplish as chief executive. Pride in his adopted country, personal ambition, and his own greed caused Walker to bolt the Liberal party, accept nomination by the Conservatives, and become the only American to hold office as President of Nicaragua.

Although President Franklin Pierce extended diplomatic recognition to the new government, the Walker regime was tottering. Cornelius Vanderbilt employed his ships to run guns and men to the Liberals; and the British, concerned over the fate of the Mosquito Protectorate, rendered aid to the rebels. Cruelly adhering to a scorched earth policy, Walker destroyed even the city of Granada; but his cause proved hopeless. The British evacuated most of his troops, while Walker himself, on 1 May 1957, gained sanctuary aboard the American warship ST. MARY'S.<7>

Walker's dream died hard. Late in November 1857, he and a band of his followers slipped into Greytown harbor and pitched camp at Puntas Arenas. American and British warships converged on the spot to round up the freebooters. On 8 December Lieutenants James Lewis and John O. Payne led a force of American Marines ashore at Puntas Arenas. Together with a battalion of seamen, they surrounded Walker's camp, while the warships FULTON, SARATOGA, and WABASH trained their guns on the knot of filibusters. Walker wisely surrendered.<8>

Again in 1858, Walker mounted another expedition, only to be shipwrecked in a gale off the coast of Honduras. In August 1860, however, he returned to Central America. This time, he landed in Honduras in an attempt to secure a base from which to invade Nicaragua. After some initial successes, the steam warship HMS ICARUS interfered. Once he had brought Walker to bay, Captain Norvell Salmon of ICARUS accepted the American's surrender and delivered him to the Hondurans who ordered him shot. William Walker was executed on 11 September 1860.<9>

The brief, hectic career of William Walker caused the Liberal and Conservative elements to unite, for a time at least, against foreign intervention. After his death, the coalition dissolved with the Conservatives gaining the upper hand. From 1863 to 1893, they avoided the pitfalls which might lead to rebellion. Two rail lines were built during this era, the first from Corinto to Leon and a second from Managua to Granada. Farmers enjoyed greater prosperity, and the educational system was reformed. The Liberals, of course, were not satisfied; but there was no burning issue upon which to base a call to arms.<10>

Relations between Nicaragua and Great Britain also improved once the Walker menace had ended. By the Treaty of Managua, 1860, Great Britain recognized Nicaragua's sovereignty over the Mosquito Coast but extracted a pledge of self-government for the Indians. Throughout the 30 years of domestic stability, Nicaragua lived up to the terms of the agreement.<11>

Strange as it may seem, it was the Conservatives, members of the party in power, who triggered the revolution which ended this era of peace. President Roberto Sacasa was a Conservative from the city of Leon. Although he owed his success to the aristocrats of Granada, he could not break the ties that bound him to his native city. The manner in which Sacasa continued to reward his Liberal friends aroused the wrath of his own party, and the Conservative ranks split with the disgruntled element raising the cry of rebellion. Quick to take advantage of the dissension within Conservative ranks was Jose Santos Zelaya, a citizen of Managua. The Liberals sprang to arms and routed their political foes.<12>

A renewal of civil strife in Nicaragua was an invitation for foreign intervention. Early in 1894, a British warship anchored at Bluefields to halt alleged infringement upon the treaty rights of the Mosquito Indians. By the year's end, however, Britain forfeited control of the reservation to Nicaragua.

The United States, also, was forced to intervene to protect American property at Bluefields. On 6 July 1894, Lieutenant Franklin J. Moses led ashore a contingent of Marines from the COLOMBIA. On the last day of the month, reinforcements were landed from the MARBLEHEAD. Both detachments were withdrawn on 7 August.

All in all, the Zelaya administration was among the most turbulent that Nicaragua had yet to experience. In 1896, the Liberals balked when the President decided to succeed himself in office; but he was able to enlist enough Conservative strength to remain in office. From 2 to 4 May 1896, when fighting near Corinto endangered American holdings, 15 Marines, under 1st Sergeant Frederick W. M. Poppe, and 19 seamen stood guard.

War again broke out in 1898, as Zelaya extended his tenure for still another term. The local United States consular agent requested the USS ALERT, at anchor in the harbor of Bluefields, to stand by in case of an attack on the city. On the morning of 7 February, the American flag rose union downward over the consulate. In answer to this distress signal, a force of 14 Marines and 19 seamen was landed. On the following day, the government forces agreed to guarantee the safety of all foreigners, and the landing party was withdrawn.

A similar landing, 16 seamen and Marines and a Colt automatic gun, took place at Bluefields on 24 February 1899. Again, a display of force was enough to prevent both rebels and government troops from destroying American property.<13>

The Zelaya administration combined Liberal idealism with graft and aggression. On the credit side, the dictator overhauled the public school system and strove ceaselessly to attract foreign industries to Nicaragua. The achievements, unfortunately, were more than outweighed by the fact that he ran the government for his own gain. The president and members of his cabinet held a monopoly over the nation's business enterprises. Without any thought for the future, they peddled Nicaragua's national resources to the highest bidder. Goods needed by the national government were paid for in worthless scrip, and soon the country was caught in the coils of inflation.

In the field of international affairs, Zelaya resurrected the dream of a Central American republic and set out to bring all five states in the area under his sway. Both the United States and European powers were eager to restore peace in Central America, principally because war endangered their investments in the region. Since President Theodore Roosevelt considered European intervention as contrary to the Monroe Doctrine, it became the responsibility of the United States to assist in maintaining order. Roosevelt extended the good offices of his government, and representatives of the Central American states met in Washington in 1907 to negotiate a general treaty of peace. This covenant was signed, but more important, the, five republics agreed to submit their future grievances to a Central American Court of Justice.<14>

At the time, it appeared that Roosevelt had won a striking diplomatic victory. Without resorting to force, he had averted the threat of European lodgement in an area vital to the security of the United States. He had extracted pledges from each of the Central American republics not to meddle in the internal affairs of the others. Finally, the Central American Court of Justice, with member judges from each of the five states, seemed capable of keeping the peace. The only difficulty lay in the fact that Zelaya had no intention of keeping his word.

William Howard Taft succeeded Roosevelt as President of the United States. He inherited the recalcitrant Zelaya, but he also was bequeathed a domestic economy rebounding from the depression of 1907. Since there was a great deal of surplus capital available for investment abroad, Taft and Philander Knox, his Secretary of State, hoped to employ this money in their foreign policy. The result was known as "Dollar Diplomacy." Basically, their plan was to have United States diplomats encourage foreign states to borrow or buy from American banks and manufacturers. This would relieve the chronic financial burdens of friendly nations, raise their standards of living, and, by providing markets for American goods, insure continued domestic prosperity.

While Taft was encouraging Americans to invest aboard, President Zelaya was having financial problems of his own. Graft and inflation again had drained Nicaragua's treasury. The shortage of funds was a source of acute embarrassment.

A great many Conservatives were growing weary of Zelaya. Throughout his reign, the dictator had made the Granada aristocrats his whipping boys; now the time had come for revenge. Eager to help the dissatisfied Nicaraguans were the foreign businessmen who had seen their holdings sold from under them according to the whims of a fickle president. In the autumn of 1909, the two groups joined forces. Financed by foreign interests, the Conservatives landed an army at Bluefields and took the offensive against Zelaya.

Chosen to lead the Conservative revolt was Juan J Estrada, governor of Bluefields Province, an appointee of the Zelaya government. Estrada's defection to Conservative ranks gave the rebels control of almost the entire Caribbean coast.<15>

The United States at first refused to intervene. Had it not been for Zelaya's folly, there might have been no landing by Marines. Shortly after the revolt began, government forces captured two American citizens serving with the Conservative army, Zeleya had them shot as traitors. Secretary of State Knox protested at once. Convinced that the Conservatives represented the majority of the Nicaraguan people, the United States severed diplomatic relations with the Zelaya government.

The Nicaraguan dictator had victory within his grasp, for Estrada's troops were falling back toward Bluefields. To remain in the good graces of Secretary Knox, at least until the Conservative threat was exterminated, Zelaya resigned as president in favor of Dr. Jose Madriz, another Liberal politician. The United States, however, withheld recognition of the Madriz regime.<16>




NEXT: Early American Intervention, 1910~1912




Return to
U.S. Marines in
Nicaragua