~ ~ ~ ~ ~
The Election of 1928




Difficult as it might be, military operations well might prove less of a problem than policing the polls. The armed enemy had at least been pushed back into the wilderness; but agents of the two political parties were everywhere. In every hamlet were Liberal and Conservative partisans, each in favor of a supervised election--provided only that it was the other party that was supervised.

As far as the Liberals were concerned, the man of destiny was Jose Maria Moncada. With Moncada at the head of the ticket, with Sandino more or less pacified, and with a majority of voters, the Liberals looked hopefully forward to an honest count.

Head of the Conservative organization was ex-President Emiliano Chamorro but he was ineligible for the nomination. When the nominating convention became deadlocked, President Diaz immediately went into conference with Chamorro. After three and one-half hours, they emerged to announce that Adolfo Benard and Julio Cardenal would head the Conservative ticket.<85>

The election law, drafted under the supervision of Brigadier General Frank R. McCoy of the U. S. Army, was put to a severe test. First came the registration of voters, which lasted from 23 September until 7 October, and it was during this period that the Sandinistas struck. Pedron Altamirano, one of Sandino's henchmen, was given the mission of frightening the Nicaraguans away from the polls. He chose a direct approach to the problem and an effective one.

Altamirano arrived at the village of San Marcos, seven miles northeast of Jinotega, on 2 October. He found four electioneers for the Liberal party campaigning there. All four were dead when the rebels rode out of town. Drifting from town to town, killing indiscriminately, Altamirano could have put an end to registration in northern Nicaragua; but he had not reckoned with Captain Norman M. Shaw and his 45th Company.

Even though his command was scattered throughout the countryside, a few men at each place of registration, Shaw managed to throw out patrols strong enough to discourage the rebels. Not only was Shaw able to screen the polling places, he even forced Altamirano to withdraw into the wilderness. There were no further raids during the election.<86>

The only means of insuring an honest electoral count was to have Marines on the scene wherever ballots were cast. In all some 900 Leathernecks and bluejackets were needed to prevent flagrant corruption. Although an Army, Navy, or Marine Corps officer was responsible for each of Nicaragua's 13 departments, an enlisted man was in sole charge of each of the 432 polling places. The principal threats to the election were riots and repeaters. A few armed Americans or Guardia troops at each village where votes were cast was sufficient to keep order. To prevent repeating, each voter dipped his finger in red ink to show that he already had dropped his ballot in the box. Sandinistas began spreading the rumor that the ink was poisoned, but only a few superstitious Indians believed them.

In spite of Sandino, the election, held on 4 November 1928, was a complete success. About 133,000 votes were cast, almost 50,000 more than in 1924. The Liberal candidates, Moncada and Enoc Aguada, amassed a plurality of 19,000. At long last, the downtrodden Liberals had won.<87>

Both parties admitted that the election had been honest. With the election no longer a cause of interparty strife, the contending factions now battled over a newly discovered issue.

The first order of business facing the new government was the ratification of an agreement between Carlos Cuadras Pasos of Nicaragua and Dana G. Munro of Nacional. Strange to relate, this organization, although it had been existence for over a year, was not officially sanctioned by Nicaraguan law.

Nor were the Conservatives alone in wishing to exert government control over the constabulary, for President Moncada himself insisted upon some sort of police force manned and officered exclusively by Nicaraguans. Instead of eradicating the Marine-trained organization, Moncada established a category of "Voluntarios," troops responsible to Nicaraga's Chief Executiv> Naturally, they would be under the tactical control of brigade officers when operating in their field, but their existence represented some degree of emancipation from restriction imposed by the Americans.

What plagued the Americans most was the fact that time was running out. Marines could not patrol the interior forever; this campaign had to be terminated. Unfortunately, the Marines could not be withdrawn until peace had been forced upon Nicaragua, and there could be no peace until a trained native constabulary was in the field. In order to reassume her sovereignty, Nicaragua needed a police force; the Marines could not be withdrawn before the country was able to enforce its own laws. In other words, some sort of Guardia Nacional had to be whipping into fighting trim. The Americans themselves were in no position to argue with Moncada even though they feared that his volunteer organization might be turned into a plaything for local politicians.

Those Marines assigned to the Guardia Nacional toiled unceasingly with their occasionally troublesome charges. One serious incident, a mutiny at Somotillo in January 1928, marred the progress of their work; but investigation showed that this uprising was due to a lack of indoctrination among the Guardia stationed there.

All was going well for the Guardia when the election of 1928 rolled around. During these critical weeks, the entire force except for recruits was turned out to lend a hand policing the polls. Here, the nonpolitical indoctrination drummed into the guardsmen paid dividends. General McCoy, a man not easily pleased, was moved to commend the organization and its officers. After this interlude, training was resumed; and by the end of September 1929, three battalions, a total of 1,846 men, were under arms.




NEXT: Military Operations Resume, 1929-1931




Return to
U.S. Marines in
Nicaragua